Health Benefits & Concerns for Fats and Oils
Heart attack
Dietary fat independently affects heart attack risk. The
Nurses’ Health Study found that eating foods high in saturated fats (meat and dairy fat) and trans fatty acids (margarine, hydrogenated vegetable oil,
and many processed foods containing hydrogenated vegetable oil) was directly associated with
nonfatal heart attacks and deaths from coronary heart disease. Consuming foods high in monounsaturated fat, such as olive oil, and
polyunsaturated fat, as found in nuts and most vegetable oil, is linked to a decreased
risk. This same study revealed that margarine consumption increased the incidence of heart
attack, particularly among women who had eaten margarine consistently for more than a decade.
Other studies report a direct association between frequent consumption of meat and butter, and
heart attack occurrence.
Depression
The amount and type of dietary fat consumed may influence the
incidence of depression. Previous studies have found that diet regimens designed to lower
cholesterol levels may reduce death from cardiovascular disease, but may also heighten the
incidence of depression. Does low cholesterol cause depression? It appears not, since studies
have shown no adverse effect on mood in people taking cholesterol-lowering drugs. The
connection more likely has to do with the balance of fats in the diet. Diets to lower blood
cholesterol usually focus on restricting total fat intake while increasing the intake of
polyunsaturated fats (e.g., corn and soybean oil). These oils are very high in omega-6 fatty
acids, but the recommended diets otherwise lack important omega-3 fatty acids (e.g., EPA and
DHA). A high intake of omega-6 fatty acids relative to an
inadequate intake of omega-3 fatty acids (e.g., from fish and fish oil)
have been associated with increased levels of depression. People who eat diets high in omega-3
fatty acids from fish have a lower incidence of depression and suicide.
Diabetes
Fats from meat and dairy cause heart disease, the leading killer of
people with diabetes. Diets high in fat, especially saturated fat, worsen glucose tolerance and increase
the risk of type 2 diabetes, an effect that is not simply the result of weight gain caused by
eating high-fat foods. Saturated fat is found primarily in meat, dairy products, poultry skins
and dark meat. In contrast, glucose intolerance has been improved by diets high in
monounsaturated oil (e.g., olive oil). There is often difficulty in changing the overall
percentage of calories from fat and carbohydrate in the diets of people with type 1 diabetes.
However, modifying the quality of the dietary fat is achievable. In adolescents with type 1
diabetes, increasing monounsaturated fats relative to other fats in the diet is associated
with better control over blood sugar and cholesterol levels. The easiest way to incorporate
monounsaturated fat into the diet is to use olive oil. However, those who are overweight need
to be careful—olive oil is high in calories.
Gallstones
A recent study of residents of southern Italy found that a diet rich
in animal fats and refined sugars and poor in vegetable fats and fibers were significant risk
factors for gallstone formation.
Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD)
Conventional treatment includes avoidance of fatty foods.
High triglycerides
People with high triglycerides are typically advised to reduce their
weight and limit the consumption of saturated fats (found predominantly in animal products
[e.g., meat, eggs, and dairy products], and tropical oil
[e.g., palm and coconut oil]). A low-fat diet (55%
carbohydrate, 23% fat, 22% fat protein) succeeded in normalizing other blood lipids, including
fasting triglyceride levels in one trial. However, the same diet failed to normalize post-meal
triglyceride levels in a group of people with high triglycerides. These results suggest that
dietary reduction of fasting triglycerides, even if the diet controls other blood lipids, may
not be enough to provide optimal protection against coronary heart disease. Many doctors
recommend a diet low in saturated fat (meaning avoidance of red meat and all dairy except
nonfat dairy) in order to reduce triglycerides and the risk of heart disease.
Immune function
The effect of fats on the immune system is complex and only partially
understood. Excessive intake of total dietary fat impairs immune response, but some types of
fat may be neutral or even beneficial. For example, at reasonable dietary levels, monounsaturated fat, as found in olive oil,
appears to have no detrimental effect on the immune system in humans.
Insulin resistance syndrome (IRS)
The effect of dietary fat on insulin resistance seems to depend on
the type of fat eaten. Preliminary studies in animals and humans suggest that insulin
resistance is worsened with increased use of saturated fat and improved with increased use of
omega-3 fatty acids from fish; the role of other unsaturated fats is less clear. However,
diets high in monounsaturated fat have improved insulin sensitivity in both healthy people and
in people with diabetes. A diet low in saturated fat, but which allows both fish and
monounsaturated fat makes sense for people with IRS because such a diet is associated with
heart disease protection. A low-fat diet allowing fish has decreased insulin resistance in
people with IRS.
Multiple sclerosis (MS)
A survey of people in 36 different countries suggests that the types
of fat people eat might affect MS. In this report, people with MS who ate foods high in
polyunsaturated and monounsaturated fatty acids had less chance of dying from MS than those
who ate more saturated fats. In another survey, researchers gathered information from nearly
400 people (half with MS) over 3 years. They found that people who ate more fish had less risk of developing MS, while those who
ate pork, hot dogs, and other foods high in animal
(saturated) fats were at greater risk.
Stroke
The influence of dietary fat on the risk of stroke is not as clear as
it is for heart disease risk. Some reports suggest an association between increased fat
intake, including saturated fat (primarily
found in meat and dairy), and a decreased stroke risk. These unexpected findings may be due to
unique dietary conditions in the country studied (Japan) or to flaws in study design. Other
evidence suggests the opposite relationship—that people consuming more saturated fat are
at higher risk of stroke.
Evidence regarding the role of unsaturated fats (primarily found in vegetable oil, cooked
and processed foods made with vegetable oil, nuts, and seeds) is equally unclear, suggesting
that unsaturated fats may have varying effects on different types of stroke or that some
unsaturated fats differ from others in their influence on stroke risk.
Weight loss
Societies that eat less fat tend to have lower rates of obesity.
However, a low-fat diet is no guarantee of normal body weight. Sixty percent of the South
African population is overweight, despite a comparatively low fat intake (about 22% of
calories from fat). Foods with a high proportion of calories from fat should be eliminated
from the diet or limited; these include red meat, poultry skins, dark poultry meat, fried
foods, butter, margarine, cheese, milk (except skim milk), junk foods, and most processed
foods. Vegetable oil, nuts, seeds, and
avocados should be consumed in moderation, although these foods are healthful for people
without weight problems.